10 tips for improving how to measure advertising effectiveness

March 7, 2023

Knowing how to measure advertising effectiveness underpins successful marketing strategies. You need to show how your B2B ad campaigns are successful and justify the corresponding ad spend.

You know this. But do you know how to measure advertising effectiveness beyond your current metrics? Go deeper than your results from anecdotal client stories, syndicated reports and marketing analytics tools?

Getting personalized intelligence straight from your clients, potential customers and competitors gives you high quality answers to specific strategic questions. A quality B2B research partner asks the right people your questions, using the best combination of research methodologies.  

This granular level of research helps you build a deep foundation to your strategic thinking and have full confidence in your decisions – before, during and after each ad campaign. These decision quality insights help you increase the impact of your campaigns, even if your budget’s unexpectedly reduced. 

You can measure your advertising effectiveness using custom insights to empower you with confidence in your strategy. This knowledge becomes your compass as you navigate the challenges and opportunities of wider economic uncertainty, competitive marketing landscape, and a constantly evolving multi-media environment.



What is advertising effectiveness?


Advertising effectiveness is a process that evaluates if a marketing campaign is reaching its intended audience and producing the desired outcomes. Marketing is a crucial element in any brand’s success. It involves a lot of effort, resources, and money to develop a campaign that would resonate with the target audience. However, it’s not enough to just launch a marketing campaign and hope for the best. You need to know if it’s actually working or not. This is where learning how to measure advertising effectiveness comes in.

By analyzing data on the strengths, weaknesses, and ROI of a campaign, brands can make data-driven decisions and adjust their strategies accordingly. At NewtonX, we provide advertising effectiveness solutions that enable brands to get the insights they need to optimize their advertising campaigns and achieve their marketing objectives. Through our post-campaign analysis, we help brands unlock real, actionable insights that can help them supercharge future advertising strategies and drive better results.



What makes an advertising campaign successful?


Everyone’s trying to break through the noise and be top of mind. The general pillars of campaign success easily roll off the tongue. A quick search for ‘great B2B advertising campaigns’ will find many brilliant examples. But you need specific success criteria that apply to your marketing strategy.

The real measure of your ad campaign’s effectiveness is how well it met its own objectives. There’s an innumerable, diverse range of possible objectives, for example:

  • Shifting perceptions of current clients to see your brand as being more innovative
  • Increase brand awareness in a new target market
  • Ensure memorability, so that you’re top-of-mind when your customers are in market


You’re targeting your audience, solving their – and their clients’ – problems. And for that you need reliable insights into your potential customers. Knowing how to measure advertising effectiveness properly means you get a specific assessment of how successfully your campaign reaches its precise objective. 

If you’re measuring a campaign against objectives it was never designed to meet, then failure’s inevitable. 



How to measure advertising effectiveness in 10 phases


1. Embed previous success

As you start the research design phase, don’t forget to apply the lessons from your previous advertising effectiveness research.

Go back to the evaluations of your previous campaigns to optimize the next one. Explore the surprising new market it uncovered. Rectify a misperception of your brand. Focus on the paid media channel that you now know gives the best ROI.

Using NewtonX’s brand health tracking capabilities gives you an instant competitive advantage. 

As technology industry insights executive Jason Talwar notes: “NewtonX’s platform gives us continued confidence that [Tableau is] sourcing the highest quality data to drive critical business decisions.”


2. Set clear objectives

At the start of every ad campaign you need to get clarity on 3 things: objective, how you’re going to measure that objective, and when you’re going to take those measurements. Pre-launch testing, during the campaign at timed intervals, after the campaign closes – it’s important to know when you’re evaluating advertising effectiveness from the outset. And a clear objective means that everyone is clear about what ‘successful’ means in this context. 

Our ‘voice of customer’ insights helped a top financial services company create a successful advertising campaign that resonated with their target market because they invested in custom B2B research first. Crucially, we advised on the relevant job titles that would be the best targets of their survey and we fielded 500 highly specific respondents in 28 days.

Their conclusion, from the Head of Marketing: “Thank you so much for helping us dig in and define our target audience from the start. Having that kind of granularity made such a difference in our results compared to how we had done this in the past.”


3. Measure site traffic

In today’s digital age, measuring site traffic has become a crucial element in determining the success of an advertising campaign. Analyzing site traffic can provide valuable insights into how effective an advertisement is at driving traffic to a website. According to a study by HubSpot, 46% of website visitors indicate the website design as a top factor for determining the credibility of a company. Hence, it’s vital to have a website that is user-friendly and easy to navigate.

Furthermore, by analyzing site traffic, businesses can identify which advertising channels are generating the most traffic and which channels need improvement. This data can help companies allocate their advertising budget more effectively and increase their return on investment. Moreover, it can help companies identify their audience’s behavior and preferences, allowing them to tailor their advertising campaigns more accurately.


4. Review lead quality

Measuring the quality of leads is a crucial element in evaluating the effectiveness of advertising campaigns. Quality leads can help businesses generate revenue and build a loyal customer base. Lead quality can be measured in various ways:

Assessing the engagement of the leads: One way to evaluate lead quality is by measuring the level of engagement with the brand. This could include metrics such as the number of pages viewed, the duration of time spent on the site, or the number of repeat visits.

Evaluating the source of the leads: Understanding how leads are discovering a business can help determine the effectiveness of various advertising channels. Businesses can analyze which channels are delivering the most high-quality leads and adjust their campaigns accordingly.

Measuring the conversion rate: Measuring the number of leads that actually convert into paying customers can provide insights into the quality of the leads. If a significant number of leads are not converting, it may be necessary to evaluate the effectiveness of the advertising campaign.


5. Use surveys to understand reach

Gathering data on the effectiveness of your marketing campaign is crucial to optimize your advertising strategy. One way to measure the real reach of your campaign is through survey data. While it can be difficult to quantify the reach of digital ads, survey data provides valuable insights into the effectiveness of your campaigns. By identifying individuals who have seen your ads and asking them about their experience, you can assess how many people actually remember your brand and how they feel about it. Survey data can also help you understand the demographics of your audience, allowing you to refine your advertising strategy to better target your ideal customers.


6. Advertising frequency

Determining the optimal frequency for an advertising campaign is a delicate balance that can make or break its effectiveness. Overexposure may lead to customer fatigue, while underexposure may result in a lack of brand recall. It is important to find the sweet spot between the two, which requires data-driven insights and marketing technology. By analyzing past campaigns and evaluating customer response, businesses can uncover their effective frequency and make informed decisions about future ad placements. Understanding this balance is crucial to achieving a successful advertising campaign.


7. Identify which metrics need to be improved

To truly optimize your advertising campaigns, it’s important to analyze not just the overall performance, but also specific media metrics that can be improved post-campaign. Vanity metrics like impressions and clicks may look good on paper, but they don’t always translate to meaningful engagement or conversions. Instead, focus on metrics that provide deeper insight into audience behavior and campaign effectiveness, such as click-through rate, conversion rate, and bounce rate. By measuring and analyzing these metrics, you can identify areas for improvement and make data-driven decisions that lead to better results.

According to a study by Nielsen, TV remains the most effective medium for reaching consumers, but digital media is rapidly gaining ground. Social media, in particular, has become an essential channel for many advertisers. A report by eMarketer found that social media ad spending in the US is expected to reach $54 billion in 2023, up from $40 billion in 2021.


8. Media channel optimization

In the world of advertising, understanding which media channels are the most valuable is crucial for maximizing the success of your campaigns. With so many different types of media available, it can be difficult to know which ones to focus on. That’s where data analysis comes in. By analyzing the performance of each media type, advertisers can identify which ones are generating the most leads, conversions, and sales. This allows them to optimize their campaigns for maximum impact.

According to a study by Nielsen, TV remains the most effective medium for reaching consumers, but digital media is rapidly gaining ground. Social media, in particular, has become an essential channel for many advertisers. A report by eMarketer found that social media ad spending in the US is expected to reach $54 billion in 2023, up from $40 billion in 2021.


9. Test and adjust

Conduct pre-launch research on your proposed campaign, making any tweaks before you invest in taking it to market. Be certain.

For example, Adweek partnered with NewtonX in order to test the prevailing theory that new data privacy policies would lead to more ad spend with publishers. After surveying 80 senior marketing decision makers in just 5 days, NewtonX delivered a 2023 advertiser spending report,  pinpointing where they intend to prioritize their advertising spend, their budget allocation divided between platforms and publishers, and the true size of these changes in ad spend.

Mark Stenberg, Adweek Senior Media Reporter, said: “What excites us the most about publishing this information is the opportunity to turn anecdotal insights into empirical data. There is often a wide gulf between what you hear and what you can report on, due to the difficulty of finding objective evidence to back up casual insights; with these findings, I am excited to be able to do that.”


10. Evaluate advertising effectiveness

To what degree have you met your campaign objective? It’s that simple. Correlate your results with your initial success criteria. If you’re doing this at data review checkpoints during the campaign, optimize your advertising effectiveness according to your results. And at the end of a campaign you’ve got all the reliable data you need to answer the really interesting questions:

  • Did they notice and remember it? 
  • Did they have the emotional response you intended and did this make them act straightaway? 
  • Did they get it? Did you connect with them?
  • How do they see the ad sitting within your brand identity?
  • Are their perceptions of the company altered in any way? 


And you’ve got evidence-based knowledge that illuminates your next campaign’s success.



Why you should know how to measure advertising effectiveness using custom insights


Evaluating advertising effectiveness gives you actionable insights to inform your future marketing strategy. It highlights strengths, weaknesses, unexpected roadblocks and surprising opportunities. You can be confident in the conclusions you reach, the campaign’s impact on your audience, and the connections it strengthens or creates.

Investing in how to measure advertising effectiveness pays off when it comes to the ROI of the whole project. Research pre-launch, during and post-campaign maximizes your marketing budget. Because it answers your questions, with 100% verified, decision quality data. Questions like:

  • How do our current customers feel about our brand, services, and products?
  • Are potential clients aware of our brand? How do they perceive it?
  • How does our brand track against others in our industry?
  • How can we optimize all levels of the marketing funnel?
  • Which paid media channels deliver the highest ROI?
  • Which campaigns are the most effective for retention, recall, and conversion?


The NewtonX Knowledge Graph scans over 1.1 billion people across 140 niche industries to find the exact professionals that can answer your question. This decision quality data is used by winning brands to build success into their marketing strategy and individual campaigns.



Why is measuring advertising effectiveness so difficult?


There are several challenges involved in knowing how to measure advertising effectiveness, commonly:

  • Sheer volume. With a multimedia strategy in place, there’s just so much to measure. Different platforms, publishers, intended audiences – you’ve already got all the basic metrics. But what about the soft data that gives you the edge?
  • Changing legal landscape. New regulations that affect your ability to measure targeted and personalized ads.
  • Bad data. And the acceptance that this is the norm. This isn’t just a financial cost. The normalization of bad data reduces any faith in the decisions made using this evidence.
  • Sources of research. Lack of custom findings based on high level insights.
  • Groupthink. Traditional, closed panels of experts produce limited results only based on current customers.



Evaluating advertising effectiveness with a reliable B2B research partner


Measuring advertising effectiveness with NewtonX means that you have access to 1.1 billion high quality, pre-vetted experts across 140 niche industries. So you’re getting your answers from exactly the right people, with 100% reliability.

NewtonX custom insights are key to the analysis of your advertising effectiveness because they provide the depth and breadth you need to make business critical decisions. We quantify the soft statistics of customer sentiment alongside the hard data to give you robust, actionable insights. Using the correct research methodologies is key: quantitative surveys, qualitative 1:1 consultations, or a combination of the two. We’re completely responsive to your specific needs.

If you want to make better decisions with B2B research, get in touch

Sign up for our newsletter, NewtonX Insights:

Your playbook to making confident business decisions enabled by B2B research. Expect market research trends, tools, and case studies with leading enterprises, delivered monthly.

Related Content

How we helped a top social media company understand how digital advertisers were thinking about their platform

A Top Social Media Company chose NewtonX and our AI-driven research methodology to launch a large brand tracking study, with the goal of analyzing its advertiser brand health.

read more

20 B2B Brand Awareness Survey Questions That Improve Strategic Planning

Asking the key brand awareness survey questions will help you assess where you stand on this crucial marketing metric.

read more

Brand Health Measurement: Why Track Brand Health Metrics?

Why and how do brands assess and report on brand health? Learn more strategic reporting analysis and metrics to get the most accurate data.

read more

Adweek: CMOs Can’t Defend What They Can’t Define

Originally published on Adweek.com by Paul Hiebert on 3/27/23.   Chief marketing officers may not always like to admit it, but there’s something borderline mystical about their craft. What, for example, makes someone who’s been

read more

TURF analysis use cases in market research

TURF analysis is a sophisticated method widely employed in market research, particularly in the realm of media planning.

read more